Skip to main content

Shelter Island NY Real Estate & Land for Sale

The median home value in Shelter Island, NY is $1,266,250. This is higher than the county median home value of $490,000. The national median home value is $308,980. The average price of homes sold in Shelter Island, NY is $1,266,250. Approximately 28.5% of Shelter Island homes are owned, compared to 7% rented, while 64% are vacant. Shelter Island real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale. Commercial properties are also available. If you like to see a property, contact Shelter Island real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Learn more about Shelter Island.


Showing Homes Nearby Shelter Island, NY
Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
24012799
Type:
Land
Lot size:
0.16 Acres
Courtesy: Cheryl A. Keithan - Coldwell Banker Realty Cheryl A. Keithan
View additional info

Build Your Dream Home in Coastal Old Saybrook! A rare opportunity awaits you... Are you ready to create your shoreline oasis? Look no further than this Fully Approved Residential Building Lot with many enticing features that make it a special gem. Come enjoy salty breezes and serene water views... sunsets and seagulls await! Located in a residential neighborhood on a road with two other homes on the street and just a stone's throw away from Saybrook Point and downtown area, easy walking or biking to most any activities offered in this quaint shoreline town. Skip the red tape! We've already secured all necessary approvals from the town. You can dive straight into building an already town approved home plan without any delays. *Our architecturally approved house plans allow for 2,096 Sq. Ft. of open living incorporating the kitchen, dining & living room for spacious entertaining plus 3 bedrooms and 3 full baths. This home features front and rear decks, 2 car garage plus a fantastic upper-level balcony/deck providing picturesque views of South Cove and beyond. Whether you envision a cozy cottage or a modern masterpiece, this lot could be your shoreline area oasis. *Price is for Lot Only.

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
170303555
Type:
Land
Lot size:
25.99 Acres
Courtesy: Joe Votto - Compass Connecticut, LLC Joe Votto
View additional info

26 Acs of private wooded land with fairway & green frontage on the Black Hall Club Championship Golf Course. Land is subdividable. Owner will assign to buyer individually the right to become a member of Mile Creek Beach Club. Great opportunity for builder or developer. Old Lyme beaches are just across the way and now is the time to grab a piece of the CT shoreline!

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
24014763
Type:
Land
Lot size:
0.12 Acres
Courtesy: John Garufi - Coldwell Banker Realty John Garufi
View additional info

Flat, level .12 Acre lot centrally located in Old Lyme (across the street from the Miami Beach Association). Close to Beaches, Marinas, Casinos, Restaurants, and Area Attractions. 2 hours from NYC and Boston. Close to I-95 and Old Saybrook Train Station. Great opportunity.

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
24003840
Type:
Land
Lot size:
8.11 Acres
Courtesy: Matt Diamond - Houlihan Lawrence WD Matt Diamond
View additional info

Picturesque waterfront 8.1 acre lot on the tranquil Oyster River in historic Old Saybrook has over 1400 ft of river frontage leading to Long Island Sound, allowing for all types of seaside recreation. This much loved pastural farmland has been privately owned for more than a century and has long been valued for its fertile soil and scenic vistas. Bald Eagles, ospreys and other rarely seen flora and fauna also make this extraordinary lot their home. The location is perfect. I-95 is easily accessible, and the lot is minutes away from Old Saybrook's beautiful beaches and charming Main Street with its quaint shops and fine dining. The sky's the limit with this lovely waterfront escape. For the more adventurous, access to boating, canoeing and kayaking are at your front door and enjoying nature on this beautiful lot can be a year-round event. Take advantage of this once in a lifetime opportunity to own your own slice of paradise. Once seen, there's no question you'll want to call this amazing piece of land home.

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
24006135
Type:
Land
Lot size:
0.14 Acres
Courtesy: Jackie Lyman - Lyman Real Estate Jackie Lyman
View additional info

A rare opportunity to purchase an approved, direct waterfront building lot, with previously approved plans for a three-bedroom, year-round home. The sale of this lot is subject to also purchasing the four-bedroom house directly across the street. However, the house can be purchased separately PRIOR to the lot selling. Imagine building your new home and having a house across the street for your family and friends to enjoy for generations to come. Grove Beach Point is one of the most beautiful, deep, sandy beaches on the CT shoreline! Come create your very own family compound. House and septic plans available upon request. See MLS #24005387 for pricing and details of the area.

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
170568798
Type:
Land
Lot size:
88 Acres
Courtesy: John Hill - Seabury Hill REALTORS John Hill
View additional info

Once in a lifetime opportunity to own 87 acres of pristine land in the charming seaside town of Old Lyme - a popular year round and summer destination. Owned by the Griswold family for generations, this idyllic property offers extensive acreage situated atop a hill providing total privacy set in nature, with the ability to create a family estate that includes scenic walking trails, a stream and ponds - all just minutes away from Long Island Sound and the beach. The land abuts permanent town nature preserves to the North, and is the only large parcel of land located in such close proximity to the shore on the market in Old Lyme. The property includes two adjoining parcels located at 28 Ben Franklin which consists of 30 acres of raw land and 32 Ben Franklin which has 57.88 acres of land with a 5302 SQ FT home. The home was originally built in 1926 but has been unoccupied for 22 years and will need to be removed or extensively renovated. The land could be developed as well, due diligence required. A very rare offering!

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
NEW LISTING
MLS#:
24015343
Type:
Land
Lot size:
4.79 Acres
Courtesy: Jennifer Caulfield - William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l Jennifer Caulfield
View additional info

This is a rare opportunity to create a fabulous residence on a large parcel of land on Meetinghouse Lane, a lovely and quiet cul-de-sac road close to the Village of Old Lyme and within walking distance of the wonderful Old Lyme Country Club. This property can also be subdivided into two already approved building lots. Permitted subdivision mapping available and a wetlands crossing has been approved.

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
170623042
Type:
Land
Lot size:
17 Acres
Courtesy: Michael Hvizdo - Coldwell Banker Realty Michael Hvizdo
View additional info

Builders and Developers Take Notice! Development Opportunity. 17 Acre Residential building lot on Middlesex Turnpike in a very convenient location near I95. Right behind multiple available Commercial and Residential building lots.

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
170623022
Type:
Land
Lot size:
124.08 Acres
Courtesy: Michael Hvizdo - Coldwell Banker Realty Michael Hvizdo
View additional info

Builders and Developers Take Notice! Very large development opportunity. 124 acres of residential land. Located on Middlesex Turnpike right next to I95. Very convenient location minutes from downtown Old Saybrook and all the town beaches. The possibilities are endless.

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
170623016
Type:
Land
Lot size:
2.65 Acres
Courtesy: Michael Hvizdo - Coldwell Banker Realty Michael Hvizdo
View additional info

Builders Take Notice! 2.65 Acre building lot on Middlesex Turnpike in very convenient location. Right next to multiple available Commercial building lots.

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
170592133
Type:
Land
Lot size:
2 Acres
Courtesy: Judy Halleran - RE/MAX on the Bay Judy Halleran
View additional info

NIANTIC SHORELINE....Welcome to LAMBERT LANDING. A rare opportunity to buy one of the last remaining lots in this 5 lot approved subdivision. Plans are available to build your dream home with one of our shoreline premier builders. This serene property is bordered by stone walls and open meadows. This building site is two acres,high and dry and extremely private. Deed restrictions of a minimum 3000 sq.ft home. Come take a tour of this beautiful property. Enjoy the village of Niantic with restaurants, museums, marinas and shopping. Just minutes to I-95 corridor - less than 2 hrs to NYC or Boston.

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
170584725
Type:
Land
Lot size:
1 Acres
Courtesy: Judy Halleran - RE/MAX on the Bay Judy Halleran
View additional info

NIANTIC SHORELINE....Welcome to LAMBERT LANDING. A rare opportunity to buy into this 5 lot approved subdivision. One of the last remaining lots available with views of the golf course. Plans are available to build your dream home with deed restriction of minimum 3000sq.ft home. This serene property is bordered by stone walls and open meadows.Come take a tour of this beautiful property. Enjoy the village of Niantic with restaurants, museums, marinas and shopping. Just minutes to I-95 corridor - less than 2 hrs to NYC or Boston.

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
170622823
Type:
Land
Lot size:
32.6 Acres
Courtesy: Tammy J. Tinnerello - William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l Tammy J. Tinnerello
View additional info

Don't miss the opportunity to acquire this extraordinary 32-acre parcel of land in Old Lyme, CT. With its vast size, stunning surroundings, convenient location, and development potential, this property offers a truly exceptional canvas for your aspirations. Embrace the chance to shape your own private oasis or embark on a visionary development project. With an expansive size spanning an impressive 32 acres, this parcel of land provides ample space for your vision to unfold. Whether you envision a grand estate, a private retreat, or a development project, this vast canvas offers the room you need to bring your dreams to life. me to explore this remarkable land and make your dreams a reality. Old Lyme is situated between Boston and New York.

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
24001759
Type:
Land
Lot size:
2.47 Acres
Courtesy: Kd Kling - William Raveis Real Estate Kd Kling
View additional info

Marina zone property with views of the water. Chance to own this 2.47 acre lot with potential, bring your ideas.

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
24014923
Type:
Land
Lot size:
0.25 Acres
Courtesy: Laura E. Cariati - Coldwell Banker Realty Laura E. Cariati
View additional info

Approved building lot south of Route 1! Use builders plans or your own! This lot has incredible views to the Hammonasset River Inlet and is located on a lovely, quiet Cul-de-sac street yet only minutes to town, shopping, train station, marina's and restaurants. Also being sold as a package deal. Please see MLS 24013799

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
170619717
Type:
Land
Lot size:
2 Acres
Courtesy: Barbara T. Myslinski-Krucko - William Raveis Real Estate Barbara T. Myslinski-Krucko
View additional info

WELCOME TO OLD SAYBROOK/SHORELINE LIFESTYLE /BEACHES/SHOPS/RESTAURANTS AND FAMOUS KATE THEATER/GREAT OPPORTUNITY TO BUILD YOUR DREAM HOME IN ASTABLISHED AYERS POINT NEIGHBORHOOD.GREAT LOCATION BETWEEN OLD SAYBROOK DOWNTOWN AND TOWN OF ESSEX/ AA-1 ZONIG/SURVEY AVAILABLE. CALL-PREVIEW-BUILD :)

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
24002702
Type:
Land
Lot size:
13.27 Acres
Courtesy: Gigi Giordano - Compass Connecticut, LLC Gigi Giordano
View additional info

Nestled on 13.27 acres of pristine raw land, this parcel boasts 617 feet of road frontage, making it easily accessible and highly visible. Situated in a prime location, it offers the perfect balance of tranquility and convenience, with wooded areas providing a serene backdrop while still being close to town amenities and beautiful beaches. The property's ample size provides ample opportunities for various uses, whether it's residential development, recreational activities, or conservation efforts. The presence of wooded areas adds to its aesthetic appeal and could potentially serve as a natural buffer or recreational space. One notable aspect is the possibility of subdivision, which could enhance its value and flexibility for future development projects. However, it's important to note that there are some wetlands on the property, which may require careful consideration and planning during any development process. This land presents a rare opportunity for investors, developers, or individuals seeking to create their own slice of paradise. With its ideal location, natural beauty, and potential for subdivision, it's a versatile property that holds immense promise for the discerning buyer.

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
170534389
Type:
Land
Subdivision:
Whippoorwill Woods
Lot size:
13.44 Acres
Courtesy: Allyson Cotton - William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l Allyson Cotton
View additional info

Excellent opportunity to build your dream home in convenient location close to Old Lyme Village, "The Woods" on Whippoorwill." This 13.44 acres parcel is close for shopping, restaurants, museums, library and short drive to beautiful White Sands Beach. Also, close to Rogers Lake for kayaking, boating, fishing, swimming and ice skating. Located on private road with electric, cable and phone lines . A beautiful lightly rolling parcel highlighted by a rock outcropping and mature trees. This subdivision is comprised of five, estate sized parcels and bounds more than 100 acres of preserve land. Wonderful for hiking, and cross country skiing, giving you privacy and tranquility, yet close to village. Easy access for to town and commuting routes. Midway between New York and Boston and just minutes from train station to Old Saybrook. 2 additional lots available.

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
170534386
Type:
Land
Subdivision:
Whippoorwill Woods
Lot size:
21.7 Acres
Courtesy: Allyson Cotton - William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l Allyson Cotton
View additional info

Excellent opportunity to build your dream home in convenient location close to Old Lyme Village, "The Woods" on Whippoorwill." This 20.70 acres parcel is close for shopping, restaurants, museums, library and short drive to beautiful White Sands Beach. Also, close to Rogers Lake for kayaking, boating, fishing, swimming and ice skating. Located on private road with electric, cable and phone lines . A beautiful lightly rolling parcel highlighted by a rock outcroppings and mature trees. This subdivision is comprised of five, estate sized parcels and bounds more than 100 acres of preserve land. Wonderful for hiking, and cross country skiing, giving you privacy and tranquility, yet close to village. Easy access for to town and commuting routes. Midway between New York and Boston and just minutes from train station to Old Saybrook. 3 lots available for your new build.

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
170560047
Type:
Land
Lot size:
32.34 Acres
Courtesy: Kevin Kennedy - Kennedy Real Estate Solutions Kevin Kennedy
View additional info

Old Saybrook, 32+ Acres for sale! How do you spell OPPORTUNITY? How about T-O-W-N L-I-N-E F-A-R-M! This is truly a rare opportunity to own over 32 acres in Old Saybrook including a working "Gentleman's Farm" with barns, farmhouse, outbuildings, pastures and beautiful treed acres with subdivision possibilities or an idyllic location for your private estate. Caution! Large animals on premises! Please do not go on property without an appointment. Thank you. Livestock not included in sale. PARCEL DETAILS: The parcel consist of tax map 62 Lot 35, 5.93 acres, a portion in forestry, zoned B-3 including a house, barn, shed & numerous outbuildings along with 26.41 acres from tax map 62, Lot 14, 15 & 16, All AA-1 Zone and in forestry. Being sold as-is.

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
170617612
Type:
Land
Lot size:
26.96 Acres
Courtesy: Katherine Ing - William Raveis Real Estate Katherine Ing
View additional info

26.96 acres of elevated, treed land. Located just north of the new Big Y and the new high school; the land is located between Killingworth Turnpike (Rte 81) to the east and Stonewall Lane to the west. 1.6 miles from Exit 63 on I-95. Preliminary feasibility study has been done using deep tests and percolation tests. Have identified multiple buildable lots. See the attached report; best viewed in 24"x36" format.

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
170534391
Type:
Land
Lot size:
12.78 Acres
Courtesy: Allyson Cotton - William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l Allyson Cotton
View additional info

Excellent opportunity to build your dream home in convenient location close to Old Lyme Village, "The Woods" on Whippoorwill." This 12.78 acres parcel is close for shopping, restaurants, museums, library and short drive to beautiful White Sands Beach. Also, close to Rogers Lake for kayaking, boating, fishing, swimming and ice skating. Located on private road with electric, cable and phone lines . A beautiful lightly rolling parcel highlighted by a rock outcropping and Southwest exposure. This subdivision is comprised of five, estate sized parcels and bounds more than 100 acres of preserve land. Wonderful for hiking, and cross country skiing, giving you privacy and tranquility, yet close to village. Easy access for to town and commuting routes. Midway between New York and Boston and just minutes from train station to Old Saybrook.

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
170594318
Type:
Land
Lot size:
18.39 Acres
Courtesy: Carol York - For Sale By Owner Connecticut Carol York
View additional info

This beautiful 18+ acre property is ideal for a potential subdivision or your personal estate. Driveway and bridge are already in place leading to the private, cleared, and lightly wooded homestead. Looking for a place to garden, hunt, ride your dirt bikes/quads/snowmobiles? This is it! Feel like you're out in the country, yet you'll have easy access to I-95 and all the amenities the town has to offer. The property includes two frontages on N. Bride Brook Road (50' and 60') - to view the property use the driveway between #'s 146 and 152. Could make 2-3 large lots or multi-family situation - buyer to do due diligence regarding subdividing.

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
170618663
Type:
Land
Lot size:
3.14 Acres
Courtesy: Alexa Scott - RE/MAX Alliance Alexa Scott
View additional info

Discover the perfect canvas for your dream home in this prime land for sale near marinas, beaches and highway. Direct pond views and a private, rear lot setting, this parcel offers tranquility and scenic beauty nestled in an established subdivision. Approvals in place for a 3-bedroom septic system. The lightly wooded surroundings create an ideal environment for constructing your dream residence. Marvel at beautiful stone walls accentuating the landscape, providing both character and direct access to the pond. This is a desirable neighborhood that presents an opportunity to create a home perfectly tailored to your preferences. Bring your plans and your builder to seize the chance to build your dream home and enjoy all that the Connecticut shoreline has to offer - a rare gem awaiting the realization of your vision!

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
MLS#:
170577297
Type:
Land
Lot size:
2.87 Acres
Courtesy: Jennifer Gurnell - William Raveis Real Estate Jennifer Gurnell
View additional info

983 Boston Post Road, Madison, CT - Walk to Downtown Madison Center. This is a rare opportunity to build the home of your dreams in Madison - one of the most picturesque communities on the Eastern Connecticut Shoreline! Perfect proximity to town, beaches and schools. Madison is acclaimed for having a top ranked school system. A-2 Survey Map with proposed home and septic location on 2.87ac parcel. Perc and Deep Hole Tests. Amazing spot to build your dream home. Close to Hammonasset State Beach, East Wharf Town Beach, Safe Harbor Marina's, Golf Courses, and Restaurants. Easy access to New York City or Boston with flights out of New Haven or catch the Shoreline East Train, Metro North or Amtrak. Frustrated losing out on multiple bids? Great time to build what you want. Have builders to help make your dream home a reality.

This Information is from Smart MLS and has been compiled from various sources, all of which may not be completely accurate. Smart MLS makes no warranty or representation as to the accuracy of listing information. All information that influences a decision to purchase a listed property should be independently verified by the purchaser. Copyright 2017 Smart MLS, Inc. All rights reserved.

How may I help you?

Get property information, schedule a showing or find an agent






We respect your privacy


Realty Assoc., LLC ~ 2239 Main Street ~ Glastonbury, CT 06033
Phone: 860-633-2192 ~ Email: [email protected]

@2022 Realty Assoc., LLC. All rights reserved.

CENTURY 21®, and the CENTURY 21 logo are registered service marks owned by Century 21 Real Estate LLC. Realty Assoc., LLC. fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and the Equal Opportunity Act. Each franchise is independently owned and operated. Any services or products provided by independently owned and operated franchisees are not provided by, affiliated with or related to Century 21 Real Estate LLC nor any of its affiliated companies.