The median home value in Old Lyme, CT is $465,000.
the county median home value of $270,000.
The national median home value is $308,980.
The average price of homes sold in Old Lyme, CT is $465,000.
Approximately 36.5% of Old Lyme homes are owned,
compared to 7.5% rented, while
53.5% are vacant.
Old Lyme real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you like to see a property, contact Old Lyme real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Learn more about Old Lyme.
Enjoy the bay and beach views from the picture windows or deck! This charming bungalow is in immaculate condition and offers a nice open living room and dining room with plenty of seating, two beautiful picture windows to enjoy the view, a propane stove for the chilly nights and wonderful enclosed front porch. There are three nice size bedrooms plus a fourth bedroom that sleeps 6-8 on the second level in the finished loft space. The large eat-in kitchen with warm custom made pine cabinets has endless possibilities. You'll love the generous sized yard for outdoor activities or evenings around your fire pit and there is also plenty of room for parking for you and your guests! This delightful cottage is being sold completely furnished and is tastefully decorated. The Point O' Woods Association offers a private beach, boat basin, pavilion, boardwalk, tennis courts, basketball courts, bocci courts and endless summer recreational activities. Easy access off I-95 and close to Amtrak to Boston and New York as well as the Metro North commuter Rail to New York.
Introducing Premier living near Black Hall Golf Course, to be built, in Old Lyme by Reagan Homes. Meticulously designed with attention to detail, this Colonial farm style home boasts contemporary architecture, spacious interiors, and an abundance of natural light. There is a builders allowance for kitchen appliances. The convenient open floor plan allows an easy flow throughout the home. The primary en-suite has a soaking tub and full sized shower. There are three more large guest bedrooms with en suite bathrooms. Working from home is simplified with your in home office space!! Enjoy the allure of a home where front and rear porches serve as fantastic spaces for entertaining. Close to Old Lyme Beaches, Old Lyme Country Club and across the street from Horseneck Creek Landing. Come enjoy all Old Lyme has to offer!!
Welcome to 6 Landing Road, a renovated Cape Cod style home in Old Lyme. This beautifully renovated 3-bedroom Cape offers a perfect blend of modern amenities and Ct. river access. Step inside and enjoy this thoughtfully designed interior that combines a traditional Cape with the convenience of modern living. The open-concept living space has gleaming hardwood floors, creating a welcoming ambiance for both relaxation and entertainment. The center of the home is a fully equipped kitchen with stainless steel appliances, white shaker style cabinetry, and quartz countertops. Also on the main level is a spacious living room with wood burning fireplace and a primary en suite. On the second level, there are two more spacious bedrooms and a newly renovated full bath. One of the many highlights of this property is its proximity to the Connecticut River. This home is part of the Binney Road Association which includes access to the dock and Ct. river. Whether you're captivated by the historic charm of Old Lyme or enticed by the Connecticut River, this renovated Cape is a testament to a lifestyle of comfort and sophistication. Don't miss the chance to make this your forever home in a community that seamlessly blends the past with the present. 2 Hours to Boston and New York.
Charming beach community of Old Lyme, this ranch-style home offers a perfect blend of coastal living and modern comfort. Located in the sought-after Miami Beach association, this residence is a haven for those who appreciate the tranquility of a private beach setting. Step inside, and you'll discover a thoughtfully remodeled interior that seamlessly combines classic charm with contemporary design. The three bedrooms provide comfortable living spaces, each designed to maximize space and functionality. The full bathroom features modern fixtures and tasteful finishes, ensuring a relaxing retreat. The heart of this home is the custom kitchen adorned with stainless steel appliances and quartz countertops. The tile floors add a touch of elegance. The outdoor shower perfect for rinsing off after a day spent at the beach. C/A. The proximity to the beach is a major highlight, allowing residents to enjoy the sun, sand, and surf just a short walk from their doorstep.
Introducing Premier living near Black Hall Golf Course in Old Lyme! Meticulously designed with attention to detail, this farm style home boasts contemporary architecture, spacious interiors, and an abundance of natural light. There is a builders allowance for kitchen appliances. The convenient open floor plan allows an easy flow throughout the home. The primary en-suite has a soaking tub and full sized shower. There are two more large guest bedrooms with a shared bath. Working from home is simplified with your in home office space!! Enjoy the allure of a home where front and rear porches serve as fantastic spaces for entertaining. Close to Old Lyme Beaches, Old Lyme Country Club and across the street from Horseneck Creek Landing. Come enjoy all Old Lyme has to offer!!
Available for the first time, Ridgeview Estates. These two contiguous parcels of land are being sold together, offering 135 acres for a beautiful subdivision with distant views of the Baldwin Bridge from the ridgeline. Please note town records have property described as having no frontage. There is frontage from two areas that are described in the deeds. Seller has worked with an engineer on preliminary designs for development. There is an electric easement to the parcel described as "5 Stage Coach Rd". The Seller will be providing a lot revision from the aggregate to remove the organic burial site.
Cozy 2 bedroom house in Miami Beach. Walk to water. Rare Year round rental in beach community. Enjoy beach life in every season!
Welcome home to this Stunning remodeled 2 family Seasonal home now available in Old Lyme! Only 200 feet or a 1 minute to and from the beach. This is an amazing opportunity for Investors and owner-occupants. With Rental rates at $450 per night per unit in season! Beautifully refinished throughout the interior in 2020, with a New Roof and siding being done this year! Complete with an outdoor shower, this 6-bedroom home has enormous potential on the shoreline!
This newly renovated colonial, located in the Old Farms subdivision, is situated on 1.84 acres set back from the street offering a private and refined setting. The 4 bedroom 21/2 bath home has been tastefully updated to reflect today's current trends. The main front entrance foyer leads to the formal front to back living room with a brick fireplace, beautiful hardwood flooring and custom size windows letting in plenty of natural light. A newly designed kitchen includes all new cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, quartz counters, tile flooring and center island with a drop leaf that accommodates seating for two. There is a large framed opened pass through to the dining room providing a sense of space and adding ease when preparing and serving family meals. From the kitchen, step down to the spacious family room that has its own separate entrance from the front covered porch. A second custom brick wood burning fireplace is the focal point of the room. Sliding glass doors lead to the covered deck and patio areas offering the perfect setting for private backyard entertaining. The second level of the home offers three generous sized bedrooms and a primary bedroom with full bath. A second full bath with double sinks and quartz counters completes this level. Additional updates include all new windows and doors, a new heating/air conditioning system and a new electrical panel and meter. There is nothing left to do but move in and unpack!
The Perfect Country Retreat, halfway between NY and Boston, this Pristine Antique is located in the heart of Old Lyme Village and enjoys views of the iconic, famously photographed, Congregational Church steeple. Drenched in sunlight and furnished in a sophisticated contemporary style, the floorplan of this home is ideal for work and play. Large gourmet Kitchen, 2 Separate Living Spaces with 3 Bedrooms, 3 Full and 1 Half Baths. There is an Office Space on the 2nd Floor as well as a detached studio to get away and relax and work in quiet separate from the Main House. The outdoors is especially tranquil and private and includes a meditation garden. This rental is for someone looking to secure the entire 6 month term from Dec 1 - May 31, and for a maximum of 4 persons. House is fully equipped...bring your tooth brush and enjoy the peace. Credit Check, Security, Lability Insurance and Cleaning Fee Additional. This home is located on the CT Shoreline along the I 95 Corridor, is easily accessible by Amtrak and is known for it's art galleries and museums, gourmet restaurants and quiet beaches and hiking trails. Spend your winter surrounded by great natural beauty that provides endless outdoor recreational pursuits or just relax by the fire and enjoy the quiet of an idyllic New England village.
Nicely located in the center of Old Lyme's historic village, the home is ideally connected to the Old Lyme art community & the quintessential New England era lifestyle. Prior to being most recently purchased in 2020, it had been within the same family for over 100 years. As you enter the fully covered screened front porch, you'll quickly realize that it's ideal for entertaining or just simply relaxing! Once stepping into the main foyer from the porch, you're greeted by early 20th century craftsmanship with the original trim & moldings as well as 6 panel doors with period hardware. The living room, dining room with fireplace & office/study with high ceilings and hardwood floors flow together nicely. The ambient light flows through the country kitchen with it's adjacent butlers pantry, half bath & small enclosed porch with back exterior staircase. Then upper level sleeping quarter offers 4 bedrooms, a study, ideal as a small 5th bedroom and 2 baths. The primary bedroom includes a walk-in closet/dressing room & all rooms on this level feature hardwood flooring. Recent improvements include newer windows, a Buderus boiler & updated 200 amp electrical service. Other amenities include a 1 car garage, full basement and attic space, all ideal for storage. Walk to all the village attractions or take a bike ride or short drive to the exceptional Old Lyme beaches. Located halfway between NYC and Boston, this home with it's exceptional location is a true CT Shoreline classic!
Welcome to Oakridge, a hidden gem and one of Old Lyme's best kept secrets! Relax in this newly renovated center chimney gem. A quintessential New England stonewall frames the approach to this saltbox style home. Outside, find a 2023 new roof, copper accent chimney flashing, vinyl siding and gutters. Inside, find an incredible right-sized design. The center hall is flanked left and right by a formal living room with fireplace and a dining room. A beautifully updated kitchen has quartz tops, tile backsplash and stainless appliances with induction range. A fireplace with woodstove insert bridges the space between kitchen and great room. Hardwood floors are found throughout. The kitchen and baths have updated tile floors. Upstairs find a spacious primary bedroom updated full bath, large walk in closet and two additional bedrooms and a renovated full bath. There is an additional 400 SF of heated, partially finished walk out basement, a faux bookcase wall and plenty of storage! Outside, there is room for pets and a swingset. Here's the secret: a private lane leads to one of the most stunning private beaches on the Connecticut coast with a protected cove and fine powder sand. A gentle grade to deeper water is perfect for swimming and legendary "Crab Rock" entertains tweens for hours! For those who enjoy kayaking, store the kayak and launch from the beach. Larger boats access to Long Island Sound via the boat launch. You'll create 1,000 memories here!
Be Ready to Enjoy the Shore in 2024! Come to the beach and indulge with two homes in one....Really! This Beach House offers 3 Bedrooms, a Full Bath and Full kitchen on each floor, along with washer/dryer (conveys) on one floor and hookups on the other. Enjoy your time with family and friends and then you can each retire to your own sanctuary when the day is done! Both floors have private access, open floor plans, enclosed porch and access to the oversized patio and yard. The circular driveway with paved side area offers plenty of parking for your get togethers, reunions, and all that are invited to join you at the beach for the day, summer season, or anytime during the year. Spend the holidays at the shore and you have two kitchens for the biggest feast ever!! A very short distance to the beach With Parking!! Gated in the Summer Season for privacy, Golf Carts are allowed with Association Registration. There are 2 new microwaves and 2 new dishwashers (still in the box!) that will be included in the sale. The home does have split units for cooling but is set up to convert to central air if desired. Both bathrooms have been updated. This is a unique property that needs to be seen to appreciate the "Two Homes in One" concept. Make your appointment to view this wonderful opportunity soon!!
Wonderfully updated, YEARLY RENTAL in Old Lyme CT! Come and live near the shore Year-Round! A very short distance to the Beach! Enjoy the beautiful sunroom or relax on the expansive, two-tiered deck, all overlooking the yard on this Private corner lot in an established neighborhood. All the large bedrooms have plenty of room for you to stretch out! The finished lower level, with Half Bath, would make a great office/play/movie area. The open floor plan lends itself to a quiet get together, dining with friends and family or a fun filled game night! Easy access to I-95, trains, and Tweed Airport for those that that need to commute. Wi-Fi included in the monthly rental price. Property is limited to 4 Occupants, Per Owner. Credit and Background Check Needed. Pet considered.
Can't find what your looking for, build your dream house(or 2?) This beautiful property is in the heart of Old Lyme Village and the last building lot on Lyme Street, don't miss the opportunity to build your forever home. This parcel may be sub dividable into two building lots with details shown on the available surveyor's map. Long admired for it's iconic iron fence, mature plantings and a springtime meadow of daffodils. The property abuts the Old Lyme Land Trust in the rear and is flat, partially cleared and easily walkable. A short stroll to award winning schools, library, museums, galleries, shopping and the Lieutenant and CT Rivers. Conveniently located to Old Lyme beaches, hiking trails, I-95, rail service and only 2 hours to NY and Boston. Enter through the iron gate by the sidewalk on Lyme Street-look for the sign.
If you are searching for a home that offers comfortable single-level living in a beautiful lake community, this is it. Enjoy the lake lifestyle with access to the stunning Roger's Lake. This oversized 2-bedroom 1-bathroom home is your answer to tranquility. This location offers a peaceful environment and a private backyard. Enjoy a short walk to the lake and indulge in activities such as boating, water-skiing, swimming fishing the town boat launch.
Waterfront Year-Round Two-Family Home directly on Long Island Sound overlooking sparkling, tranquil blue waters with a large, private, sandy beach in desirable Hawks Nest Beach! Relax and rejuvenate in the ocean air and sea breezes. Quintessential beach cottage where a lifetime of memories are made! A two-family home with two completely separate units, each with an eat-in Kitchen open to a Living Room, a Sun-filled Enclosed Porch overlooking the beach and water, and each include three bedrooms and one full bathroom on each side. Almost every room has a Waterview. You can rent one side and enjoy the other! So many water activities to enjoy, swimming, paddle boarding, sailing, and more. Charming, Shoreline, community features art galleries, restaurants, an historic district, and shopping, tennis and golf nearby. Cross Lane Park features basketball and tennis courts for more recreation. Conveniently located only two hours from New York and Boston. Amtrak train nearby. Once in a lifetime opportunity where a lifetime of memories are made!
Amazing opportunity to stay in this beautiful beach home located in the highly desired Old Lyme Shores Beach Association! Boasting 3 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, central air, and stunning water views, this home will surely make for a wonderful stay! Available for academic rental - 10/16/23 - 4/19/24.
Available Now through Mid-June of 2024! This is not a Year Round Rental. Come enjoy wonderful marsh views during the Off Season in Old Lyme CT. This property is located near the shore, but close to I-95, Tweed Airport in New Haven and trains to NYC, Boston and beyond. Get away, but stay close to easy travel for commuting. Plenty of room for you to enjoy with Main Floor, Oversized Kitchen, Large Living Room, Full Bath, Dining Room with water views. What better place to spend the fall, winter and spring?? The property is limited to 4 occupants, per owner. No Pets and no smoking please. Fireplace pictured is not for use. Decroative only. Tenant(s) to pay utilities. 1st, Last and Sec. Deposit needed (62 or Older, 1st and Sec. Deposit) Credit/Background Check needed. References and proof of employment may be required.
Cold storage space. Park-like setting. Great location right off I-95. Zone: LI80. Shelving available - second floor.
A rare opportunity to own a charming year-round beach home located in Point O'Woods! This Long Island Sound community of homes is rarely available for sale! Enjoy panoramic views of the marina, beach, marshlands and LI Sound from the enclosed front porch or the expansive (over 500 sq') of Trex deck with cedar posts and clear view stainless steel railing. This home is turn-key, with a freshly painted modern interior, new roof, gas fired warm air, and central air. Featuring 3 bedrooms, 1 full bathroom plus the outdoor shower/changing room you expect in a beach home! Enjoy an open concept living space, plus a bonus family room in the lower level walk out. Warm up next to the cozy propane fireplace during the winter months. The outdoor space is amazing with professionally built CT granite gardens and retaining wall, and beautifully landscaped with annual and perennial beds. This home has updated mechanicals, city water and sewer. Association amenity list is extensive with private beach access and boardwalk to a pristine beach, potential boat slip at the boat marina, tennis courts/pickleball courts (there is an annual tournament!), basketball court, bocce courts and a pavilion that overlooks the playground. The active association holds annual ice cream socials, movies on the beach, bands, a dinner dance, decorated golf cart parades and so much more! Easy commutes from all cities (Boston, Hartford, New York) -Escape to the beach and relax with the stunning sunsets and views!
Winter on the Lake... Escape to this cozy 3 bedroom 1.5 bathroom WATERFRONT Cape on Rogers Lake. Enjoy beautiful views of the lake and wildlife throughout winter months in this furnished rental available until May 1st. This sun-filled home boasts a great layout with a large kitchen with natural wood cabinets, tiled floor and a deep SS sink. Parquet flooring flows throughout this lovely home and invites guests into the formal living room with a woodstove and access out to the three season sunroom which is the perfect spot to relax and take in the lake life. A full bathroom appointed with a tub/shower combination and a primary bedroom round out the first floor. The upper level features two more generously sized bedrooms, a office/4th bedroom and a convenient half bathroom. If lake freezes enjoy ice fishing and skating throughout the winter and in early spring enjoy kayaking and fishing off your own dock!!! Rent includes electricity and Wi-Fi. If you want to enjoy the lake life until early Spring call today...
Welcome to “Ludington House” – a Landmark historical home located on the bend of Lyme Street and in the heart of the Old Lyme Historic District. This stately colonial revival mansion’s most notable resident was Katherine Ludington, an American suffragist. Rich with history, this significant property built circa 1895 offers grand spaces, high ceilings, 8 fireplaces, intricate moldings, and retains the charm of renowned Architect Henry R. Marshall. The grand foyer welcomes you with a beautiful staircase, an arched ‘hide way’ alcove and French doors leading to blue stone terraces and gardens. The elegant dining room with an accent dark ceiling and crystal sconces add to the beauty of this grand lady. The large sunny kitchen and butler’s pantry is the heart of this home. The graceful main level opens up through French doors to wraparound porches and exterior access to a garden suite. As you climb the sweeping staircase to the second floor, you will find a generous landing leading to the private bedroom en-suites. The Primary space, behind the double doors, features a morning room, sitting area, kitchenette, his and her bathrooms and 2 bedrooms. Down the hall are the additional 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths. The 3rd floor apartment has 3 suite style bedrooms, kitchenette, living spaces and beautiful large windows. This incredible estate's grounds features expansive patios, terraces, manicured gardens, 4 bay garage/barn and is strolling distance to the charming Lyme Street Village.
Looking for temporary living in between a relocation/sale/purchase? We have the perfect home for you! Enjoy all that Miami Beach has to offer in the most relaxing months at the beach! This exceptionally clean and comfortable home is available to rent immediately through MAY 15th. There's a large eat in kitchen, light and bright living room and three spacious bedrooms with a bonus bunkbed room on the lower level. The large covered patio is wonderful for unwinding or dining alfresco after a nice day at the beach. Additional features: Central air and lots of extra parking behind home. Tenant responsible for utilities, propane, cable/internet. Credit application, lease and a credit score of 680 or higher required. No Cats please. Rent for as little as three months at a modified monthly rate of $2200/Mo.
Academic/Off-Season RENTAL!!! Stunning Custom Colonial, a dream come true for all that want to live in Grand Style on the CT Shoreline! Expansive patios, Front porch & spacious yard, property has room to enjoy. Lower level has open concept kitchen, fully finished with everything needed (For anyone that enjoys Cooking!). Off the kitchen is an office for working remotely. 2 well-appointed, Living Rooms w/Gas Log Fireplaces are the gathering place for Movies, Game Night, or a good place to get away! Also Downstairs: Laundry, ½ Bath, Media Closet & Storage/Pantry Closet. Upstairs are 2 full baths and 4 bedrooms. Primary Suite is a Suite! Full Bath & private deck with views of the water! Entire property is well appointed and waiting for those that look for the best! A short distance to the beach, enclosed outdoor shower with changing area, for after fun in the waves, sun and sand While the Warm Weather is here!! All Rentals: $600 cleaning fee, guests to leave the property in the same condition as found, do not leave belongings or food and dispose of all trash in exterior bins. 1 to 3 Months, $5800/Month, Includes Utilities. Full term, Oct 1 to June 8, 2024, $4000/Month, Tenant(s) Billed for Utilities. Start Date may be negotiable if needed earlier. Limited to 6 Occupants per owner. Credit/Background is very important to owner.